Native sea oats above a quiet shell-flecked Venice-area beach and calm pale-aqua Gulf water in soft November sunshine.

Venice Starts This Season With Fewer Homes for Sale

November 19, 2026

In the Venice area, the winter season used to fill up the for-sale list. Last winter it barely did. From October 2025 to January 2026, active listings in the Venice Area Board of REALTORS® territory rose from 1,099 to 1,183. After that, they fell every month through July, even as sales ran ahead of the year before. That count is climbing again now, but from a lower starting point. The October 2026 report shows 807 active listings, about 27 percent fewer than the 1,099 recorded in October 2025.

Many buyers who plan a Venice purchase around a January or February visit expect the winter months to bring the most choice. For two of the last three seasons, that was true. Last season it was not, and this season begins with less supply than last. If you are planning to shop this winter, here is what the numbers show.

Two winters, side by side

The Venice Area Board of REALTORS® (VABR) publishes a monthly report compiled from Stellar MLS data. Its territory reaches beyond the City of Venice. In August 2026, Sarasota County accounted for 84 percent of the board's sales and Charlotte County for 11 percent. These are area-wide figures, not counts for the island or for a single ZIP code. The four-year history at the back of the October 2026 VABR report lets you put the last two winters next to each other.

Month Active listings, 2024–25 season Months of inventory Active listings, 2025–26 season Months of inventory
October 1,045 6.57 1,099 5.72
December 1,220 7.97 1,117 5.88
January 1,474 9.21 1,183 6.88
February 1,607 9.98 1,159 5.15
March 1,632 7.29 1,133 3.87
April 1,609 6.21 1,059 3.69

In the 2024–25 season, inventory rose by close to 600 listings between October and March. Buyers in February 2025 were looking at nearly ten months of supply, meaning it would have taken almost ten months to sell every listed home at that month's sales pace. In the 2025–26 season, inventory added fewer than 100 listings at its January peak. By March 2026, supply was under four months.

Sales picked up instead. From January through April 2026, the board recorded 977 sales (172, 225, 293 and 287). The same four months of 2025 had 804. Closings ran about a fifth higher than the winter before, and the for-sale list stayed close to flat.

The count heading into this winter

Inventory reached its 2026 low in summer, at 793 listings in July and 745 in August. It then rose to 764 in September and 807 in October. That fall rise is the normal seasonal pattern, and it happened in each of the three falls before this one. Each of those Octobers started with more homes for sale: 962 in 2023, 1,045 in 2024 and 1,099 in 2025.

October 2026 had 157 sales at an average sale price of $467,618, with sellers receiving 96 percent of their final list price. Supply was 5.14 months. That supply figure is higher than it was in spring because fall sales are seasonally slow, not because the number of homes for sale has grown much. October 2025 had 192 sales.

The countywide numbers point the same way. In September 2026, Sarasota County had 2,629 single-family homes for sale, down 16.2 percent from a year earlier, and 3.7 months of supply, according to the Sarasota-Manatee REALTORS® September 2026 single-family summary. The median sale price that month was $485,000, up 7.8 percent from September 2025. Homes took a median of 51 days to go under contract, and sellers received 94.3 percent of their original list price. The Sarasota Herald-Tribune's third-quarter report quoted association president David Crawford: "Even with new listings increasing across all segments, inventory continues to shrink, showing buyer demand is outpacing current supply."

The same Herald-Tribune report also found that new pending single-family sales in the July-to-September quarter fell from a year earlier in both Sarasota and Manatee counties. Fewer contracts going into fall could leave a few more homes on the list by January. The low starting count is the more certain fact, and a buyer planning a winter visit should plan around it.

Waiting until November doesn't buy much of a discount

Some buyers reason the other way. If winter brings competition, then shopping in late fall, before the seasonal buyers arrive, should bring a better price. The county's 2025 monthly data shows that the gap between seasons is real but small.

Across Sarasota County in 2025, single-family homes took a median of 54 days to go under contract in November and 51 days in December. From January through April, the medians ranged from 40 to 46 days. Sellers received 93.3 percent of original list price in November and 93.5 percent in December, against a range of 93.1 to 94.5 percent from January through April. April 2025, in the middle of season, came in at 93.1 percent, below both November and December.

So a late-fall buyer gets a little more time to decide, maybe a week or two of market time on a typical home. The final price shows almost no seasonal discount. Shopping now pays off in having more time and fewer competing offers. It does not reliably pay off on price.

Where the room to negotiate is

Price bands tell a more useful story than seasons do. In VABR's October 2026 report, the $400,000 to $499,999 range was the busiest. It had 27 sales at 97 percent of list price, a 64-day average on market, and 134 active listings. The $1,000,000-and-over range had 6 sales at 90 percent of list, with 54 listings. In September, $1,000,000-and-over sales closed at 86 percent of list after an average of 141 days on market.

The year-to-date figures make the same point. Through October 2026, the board recorded 358 sales between $400,000 and $499,999 at 96 percent of list, and 90 sales at $1,000,000 and over at 91 percent of list. At this year's pace of about 36 sales a month, the 134 listings in the $400,000 band would sell out in under four months. At about nine sales a month, the 54 listings above $1,000,000 would take around six. A buyer in the middle of the Venice market is shopping in a tight segment. A buyer at the top has more homes to compare and more room to negotiate on price.

Property type matters as well. VABR's September report counted 130 single-family homes, 28 condos, 3 townhouses and 20 villas among that month's sales. At the county level, Sarasota condos and townhouses had 4.9 months of supply in September 2026. Closed sales were up 34.3 percent from a year earlier, and 63.1 percent of those purchases were cash. In a Venice Gondolier interview, VABR president Mark Soravilla described condos as pressured by rising fees and predicted a small rebound in 2026. Condo sales did pick up this year. With nearly two-thirds of condo buyers paying cash, a financed offer on a condo often competes with cash offers.

The new-construction factor south of town

The Venice market also includes Wellen Park. In the same Venice Gondolier interview, Soravilla said newer communities there set a higher bar for resale homes, partly because their fees tend to be lower. He said resale homes can sit on the market longer when they compete with builder incentives. For a buyer, this means the resale count alone understates the real choice in some price ranges. A resale listing and a builder's spec home may be competing for the same buyer. Comparing them takes care, because a builder's advertised rate is a price quoted to one kind of buyer, while a resale list price is the same for every buyer.

Soravilla also said that "Waiting for rates go back down to 3% ... it's a pipe dream." Waiting for more listings rests on the same hope as waiting for a lower rate, that the market will be easier for buyers by spring. Last winter's listing count went the other way.

Planning a winter search around these numbers

Start earlier than the calendar suggests. If you plan to visit in January or February, review listings in December so that your first trip is spent touring homes you have already narrowed down. In the middle price ranges, a home that fits your list may go under contract before your flight. Last spring's sales pace shows how quickly that can happen.

Decide where you need to be on price. Below $700,000, recent Venice-area sales have mostly closed within a few points of list price. Above $1,000,000, the board's data shows wider gaps between list and sale price. Whether to buy on the island or the mainland is a separate decision with its own tradeoffs, covered in our comparison of Venice island and mainland homes.

Plan your financing as well. With 42.1 percent of Sarasota County single-family sales and 63.1 percent of condo and townhouse sales closing in cash in September 2026, a financed buyer should have pre-approval in hand before the first showing.

Frequently asked questions

Are these numbers for the City of Venice only? No. The VABR report covers the board's full Stellar MLS territory, which in August 2026 was 84 percent Sarasota County sales. It is the closest regular monthly read on the Venice area, and it does not split the island from the mainland. For current homes, the Venice homes for sale search shows what is available today.

Will inventory keep rising through winter? In each of the last four seasons, the count has risen from October into January. Last season the January peak was 1,183 listings. This season starts from 807, so even a similar rise would leave fewer homes for sale than last January.

Is now a good time to sell in Venice instead? Sellers in the busiest price ranges are competing with fewer listings than a year ago, and the home valuation page is a starting point for pricing your own home against them.

If you are planning a Venice visit for this season, start the conversation in December, while the listing count is still low and the calendar is open. Jeanne Egan is glad to talk through what is listed in your price range and what to expect from a winter search, so your trip goes to homes that fit. Let's Connect.

Partner With Jeanne

I am committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, I've got you covered.